I had a photojournalism professor at Indiana University years ago who said to the class one day, “If I give your photograph an ‘A’ you will think I’m the greatest professor at IU, though if I give your photograph a ‘C’ you will think I’m an idiot.”
He gave A LOT of ‘C’ grades. Mostly ‘C’ grades, in fact.
For him — and I later learned he was 100% correct — a ‘C’ is an “average” photograph that one would see in a publication. A ‘B’ grade would be a better than average photo, that would catch the reader’s attention. While an ‘A’ was reserved for whether you could submit it with a straight face and clear conscience to ‘National Geographic’. Very, very few ‘A’ grades were awarded….
Siobhán and I were asked to be the jurors for the Bloomington Photography Club’s annual exhibition this year. Part of the task is to whittle down X-number of photos to simply the top 80 images, which will then be on display at the Waldron following a cocktail reception.
I have no doubt that Y-number of the folks who submitted photos that we didn’t select for the exhibition will think us idiots for not seeing their talent. I have no doubt that the photographers who captured the top three photos (chosen as such) and those who shot the top 10 images (again, chosen as such) will think us to be the greatest judge of photography talent in the Midwest. Both may be right or wrong, but, the message is this….
The field of photography has an odd element whereby a percentage of folks who take pictures don’t seem to want to get better at their craft. They want, instead, to tell you that what they’ve done is already noteworthy. They won’t improve. The people who didn’t have a photograph chosen for gallery exhibition can learn volumes by asking questions, listening carefully, taking the advice and stepping back out with renewed purpose. Some will. Most won’t.
I will personally sit down and talk with any and every person who submitted an image that was rejected. I would be genuinely enthused to help you with your craft. Contact me and let’s talk about how you can improve.
To those selected as a top 80 photo in The Bloomington Photography Club, and to the 10 top awards, I salute you and encourage you to enjoy the pat on the back but get right back to work. The next photo should always be better than the previous. Keep shooting. Keep learning. Keep improving. Don’t get too low. Don’t get too proud.
This a a gorgeous art form. We’re blessed to have the technology, equipment, freedom, free time and financial wherewithal to pursue photography. Encourage one another. Take constructive feedback. Grow.
And smile. It’s all supposed to be fun.
Read More